Man, the internet can be brutal sometimes — especially when it comes to discussions about identity and politics in Japan.
Yu Miri, one of Japan’s most respected novelists, recently posted on X criticizing the rising anti-foreigner rhetoric in politics. She pointed out how exclusionary attitudes seem to be getting more normalized, especially after last year’s elections where some parties pushed “Japanese First” slogans.
Her comments? Totally fair game in a democracy, right? Well, not according to the flood of replies she got.
A bunch of people didn’t even bother arguing with her points. Instead, they went straight for her background — she’s Zainichi Korean (ethnic Korean with deep roots in Japan) — and basically told her she has no right to comment on Japanese society or government because of it.
Yu Miri clapped back hard in one post: “I was born and raised in Japan, I live in Japan, I pay taxes in Japan. Every day since I was born, I’ve been under the influence of Japan’s government. I can’t get on board with your sophistry arguing that I should shut up because I’m a foreign national.”
Born in Ibaraki Prefecture in 1968 and raised in Yokohama, Yu Miri is a literary heavyweight. She’s won the prestigious Akutagawa Prize, and her novel Tokyo Ueno Station even scored a National Book Award in the US. She’s spent her whole life in Japan, writing in Japanese, and contributing hugely to Japanese culture. But for some critics, her heritage alone was enough to label her an outsider who should stay quiet.
The backlash got so nasty that her editor at Weekly Gendai, Hatori Ryō, stepped in publicly. He straight-up called out the discrimination and defended her right — and the right of any ethnic minorities and foreign nationals living in Japan — to speak about the society they’re part of. That move helped spark a counter-campaign pushing back against the hate.
This whole situation has blown up into a bigger conversation about who actually “belongs” in Japanese public discourse. In a country dealing with aging population, labor shortages, and immigration debates, it’s highlighting some pretty raw tensions around national identity.
Japan does have a Hate Speech Elimination Act from 2016, but a lot of that stuff has just moved online. Now the Justice Ministry is planning its first big survey on hate speech on social media — probably not a coincidence.
At the end of the day, disagreeing with someone’s politics is one thing. Telling a lifelong resident and celebrated author she doesn’t get to have an opinion because of her ethnicity? That’s something else entirely.
What do you think? Should birthplace, taxes paid, and decades of contribution matter more than ethnic background when it comes to joining the conversation? Or is this just how these debates always go online?
Let me know your take in the comments!
Be the first to comment